Public reaction is highly polarized, with strong criticism directed at Mahua Moitra for her remarks against Amit Shah, advocating for legal action, while a significant faction defends her stance on women's rights and government accountability. The comments reveal an underlying frustration with the Bharatiya Janata Party's governance, resulting in a complex sentiment landscape.

Mahua Moitra

Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)

Trinamool Congress (TMC)

&gt;"They are repeatedly talking about infiltrators; but the border of India is protected by five forces, and that is directly the Home Ministry's responsibility," she said.

&gt;Referring to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Independence Day address, she remarked, "Standing at Red Fort, the PM himself said infiltrators are causing demographic changes. But even as he was saying this, his Home Minister was standing in the front row, smiling and clapping."

&gt;She then launched a personal attack on Shah, alleging, "If we don't have anyone to protect our borders, if people from another country are entering every day, if our citizens complain that infiltrators are eyeing our mothers and sisters and snatching our lands, then the first thing you should do is cut Amit Shah's head and put it on your table."

&gt;The Krishnanagar MP also said, "When the home ministry and home minister cannot protect the nation's borders, and the PM himself says infiltrators are troubling our people, then who is at fault? Is it our fault? Or yours?" Moitra also questioned why infiltration continues despite the presence of the Border Security Force along the frontier.

one_brown_jedi

A Shah always gives vibes of someone indestructible and not in good way. More like the stories of indestructible Rakshasas we heard as kids. 

Especially that Rakhtabeej story...

waryinsomnious

Leave it to the BJP to take a metaphor literally. 😄

Juvegamer23

Any policeman who accepts a case without understanding a metaphor should be suspended. I'm sure they all write GK exams to be a cop unless they bribed into it

Dr_NitroMeth

she is useless - amit shah actually had experience on how to do it in gujarat 2002

  
How dare she try to copy him.. no body does slaughter like modi+ amit shah

Life_Machine_9694

Let infiltrators, complain about said infiltrators, claim you are the only one who can save citizens from the infiltrators ,get votes and repeat cycle.
But someone with minimum common sense knows BSF is under who.

iceman___11

Impossible_Raise2416

Namaskar u/polash_06, thank you for your submission.
We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities:
- r/Indian_Conservative 
- r/West_Bengal


*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Kolkatacity) if you have any questions or concerns.*

AutoModerator

These types of statements are common in Bengal the thing is there is no take appropriate action

Bitter_Bat5955

Bhai TMC facilitates the infiltration. Their ministers are in jail for cow smuggling

Fit_Leg4752

did i j saw someone giving deat* threats?

dumbokudi

sapan_auth

EmbarrassedGarden109

Just put her in jail. After 21 times request to mamar a she still didn’t give up land for fencing for about 1200 kilometers at the Bangladesh border. This lady is simply just vile, demonic representation.

MoronSlayer_786Lolwa

CLARIFIES the current situation of the state!

Dry-Feeling-6797

She should say same thing about Momta Bano because she is highlighting failure of law and order in state which is a State subject 

Also border of Bengal is porous at many places due to mountains, rivers etc and in that situation state police cooperation is needed for BSF which Bengal government is not providing due to Rohingyas vote bank of TMC

If she is really concerned with infiltrators then she should support NRC in Bengal

BigSweet3806

Imagine the outrage if a BJP politician would have said this about an opposition politician.

She said Bangladesh is better than India so then why not shift there, Mohua?

Long-Poetry1779

Eirokom ekbar pisi bole6lo na? J modi WB te jodi ase paa venge rekhe dbo

ddyshh

West Bengal should vote for Congress/BJP.

Connect_Rhubarb_3224

Time to arrest her for 30 days for giving death threats and then see the magic.

Vivid-Ice-1544

RoadRolla785

[deleted]

She spoke too much, hope Shah doesn’t see it!

Full-World3090

DarkPuzzleheaded6259

phoenixvc

A few months in jail should take care of the vile gutter flowing through her veins

betterdedthanred69

Send her to Bangladesh without security. She'll appreciate India more.

DoomGuy971

little_boy_20k

She should be in jail. Most of the TMC politicians should be. I mean majority of politicians are corrupt in some way or another, but TMC is just the scum of the Earth.

CarbonCrawler

Maverick5332

I'm not a fan of BJP but she should not be in indian public life.

Look up her background. Disgusting animal.

margosi

dogle log hai khud kand karke dusro pe jimedari daldenge vote bhi toj chaiye na hinduo ka sirf muslim se thodi chalega

Old-Policy-2647

She has the right to say. She is very empowered. Ask the businessmen, they know how expensive she is.

https://preview.redd.it/xe1wm5mc2xlf1.png?width=1080&amp;format=png&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=d6a41a434ab43c87d0c8dc93196cc402eeba677f

ParsleyForeign993

kakarot_goku_1907

notagaingd

Ok_Visual4618

Lagta hai piche khade mulle se apni speech taiyar karwati hai ye kathmulli madarsachap

william2115

Old_Relation_1633

djangodude786

JustDoItPika

Mohua Moitra thinks in english and translated them to bengali.

In english there's a metaphor "heads must roll" which means the ones accountable should be taken to task. I am guessing she did a literal translation of the metaphor in Bengali.

Ok-Try2512

Stop this mohua, already one leg fracture(theatric) is confirmed for the next election if you and kalyan uncle keep on talking shit didi may have to do campaign in egypt mummy style

DepartureAny7617

I wonder how much the c*nt who got paid for asking questions in parliament got paid this time😆

Themaniac007

Told you. This is a fu*king terrorist party. TMC - Terrorist Manufacturing Company. Every fu*king buddy is a chor, rapist, murderer, fraud, terrorist. The most filthy party ever. Period.

Intelligent-Score211

Unusual-Squirrel987

sunilswag

As much as you can hate her for the statement, I have seen with my own eyes the BSF around the Bangladesh border has hell bent corruption. They get money to smuggle ppl from Bangladesh to Bengal. There are villages formed by these infiltrations of Bangladeshis just over the border, not even inside . Like truly TMCP might use these as their vote bank advantage and whatever you can think of, but border with 50km inside is completely under jurisdiction of army and central power. What the hell are they doing if there's this much insecure border. Removing weeds from crops without measurements will lead to weeds again regrowing. You need to use weedicide to not allow this kind of weed growing. Border secure nhi hoga toh yeh Nahi rukega

NickFury1998

Even though I lean towards BJP but she is 💯 right

Competitive-World994

Well said... Border security is centre and BSF duty.

CryptographerShort10

She said that the BSF is controlled by the central government. 
If people from other countries are entering, it is the fault of the BSF and the central government.
What is wrong in this ?
It is known fact that there are personnel in the BSF who take bribe and let intruders enter and even let cattle be taken away.

Extreme_Diver8795

Namaskar u/Realboy000, thank you for your submission.
We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities:
- r/Indian_Conservative 
- r/West_Bengal


*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Kolkatacity) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Of course. Her ideal kind has peeled --s and they also love to cut heads. Ask the ghost of Daniel Pearl. What is this woman still doing in India, I wonder.

LingoNerd64

What about the incident where Modi said "Tukde tukde gang" ?

Any-Individual5262

Khub bhalo kreche. BJP r aro uchit jesob molla netara ( hakim miya) molla rajotto banabe ba vote e jitle thegiye Har gor bhenge felbe ityadi bole segulor biriddheo fir kora.

Bolai bahulyo police Kichui krbe na, kintu ekta public r Samne show of integrity hobe atleast

r7700

Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra has ignited a political storm with her controversial remarks suggesting drastic measures against Union Home Minister Amit Shah.

Political Controversy Over Mahua Moitra's Remarks on Amit Shah

Why This Matters

Public Sentiment Summary

Highlighted Comments

Parties Involved

What the people want